Stock Recommendation : An engine maker with EV aspirations

More like this

22 thoughts on “Stock Recommendation : An engine maker with EV aspirations”

    1. N V Chandrachoodamani

      Yes, the Co is getting noticed for its EV play. We are watching the progress on their businesses.

      1. Dear N V Chandrachoodamani;
        Thanks for your recommendation.
        i have earned good profit on this stock. i have sold my partial qty and hung up with other till your sell call comes.

        1. N V Chandrachoodamani

          Good to hear that sir

          We are watching the progress on the EV businesses. Will update our reco. based on that

          Thank you

  1. Dear Sir; The article was good and we come to know more about Greaves Cotton.
    the only query which is bothering is why the prices of the stock is coming down day by day.
    For we as investor; do we buy via SIP route ?
    how much one can allocate in this company if their portfolio is of 15-20 stocks only ( i mean in %ge terms) & holding tenure as 3-5 years.

    regards.

    1. N V Chandrachoodamani

      Thanks for your query sir

      Being a mid-sized Co, the stock price has been volatile. Even around the time of recommendation, the stock moved up quickly after Govt increased the subsidy for EV 2 wheelers

      So we had recommended to accumulate the stock in steps, on declines. The investment argument remain un-changed.
      This being a mid-sized emerging growth Co, the investment amount should be lower compared to established large-sized Cos.

  2. Thank you for the insightful report. I can see good coverage around electric vehicle segment. Also wanted to check how is core business of Company positioned? Will there be fall in this due to growth of electric segment? If yes, will this growing share of electric segment lead to margin erosion for the Company as a whole and overall still good for Company?

    1. N V Chandrachoodamani

      Appreciate your query sir

      The Co has been consciously diversifying from automotive segment in the last 3 years. Even in automotive segment, it has introduced CNG and Petrol engines as well. Despite >60% slump in 3 wheeler sales in FY21, Greaves managed to end the year with 27% decline in sales, non-auto segments have picked up well. Greaves has also consolidated engine manufacturing at a single site (Aurangabad) to save on fixed costs. All these initiatives look promising as far as its core business is concerned. Also, CNG and Diesel are here to stay in passenger as well as cargo segments in heavy duty/rural area transport applications

      EV business will be the key growth and valuation driver going forward

      We have mentioned the present valuation as well as last 5 Yr PE band. Accumulating the stock in corrections can help to get it at reasonable valuations, manage any down-side well and look for upside from the EV business

  3. Subramanian N R

    Dear Chandra, Solid analysis. Guess if I invest, should be patient enough to hold for 3 years.

  4. Great report . I was looking for perspective on the EV business of Greaves . Clearly they are well positioned , have the first mover advantage along with Hero electric . However will they be able to take on the might of well funded Ola and Hero Motors Ather ? Would be great to have your perspective on the same .

    1. N V Chandrachoodamani

      Thanks you sir

      It is very difficult to predict the order at this early stage. Greaves has built a team, product portfolio on low & high speeds and also 3W. This low speed segment also holds potential which is not covered much. Ather plays at premium end whereas Hero Motocorp’s own DNA is low end & affordable 100-125cc segment. Greaves is playing the low end space at affordable cost going further down to low speed ones. It is seriously expanding and building volumes

      Even in the conventional segment, no Co is a leader in multiple segments. We have shared some of our observations in the report

      So, early days to predict the winners or top 1,2 &3. Just need to see if the Co is doing right things and go with staggered allocation.
      It may take 2 or 3 years to get visibility on top 1, 2 & 3 players in this space

      1. Thanks for your perspective Chandra . Pls keep us updated priodically as EV is an evolving space .

  5. Very nice analysis and introduction to this stock in EV play. Please continue to bring out such articles!!

  6. Hello Sir,
    Thank you for very detailed report on emerging company . Sir Can u tell me which battery industry Is going to be in benifit.
    Regards
    Ram

    1. N V Chandrachoodamani

      Thank you sir

      It is very tricky. In 2 and 3 wheelers, standardization may be possible and existing players may tap this opportunity. In the areas of public transport also we can expect some level of standardization

      In case of passenger cars, it may not be easily possible. Design, cell chemistry, capacity and the engineering involved in assembly may vary with each Co and so we need to watch how it evolves

  7. Hello sir,
    Thanks for coming up this detailed rationale behind the recommendation.
    On the EV landscape in 2 wheelers, the current incumbants like Hero and VC backed companies like Ola have a lot of cash to burn (almost in multiples) in comparison to Greaves Cotton. Do you see any competitive advantage that Greaves Cotton has that would enable it to gain market share in the next few years when more 2 wheeler companies with deep pockets and an existing distribution network start getting into this space?
    Also, do you foresee Greaves Cotton getting to be part of the EV value chain like say supplying electric motors or any other components to different 2wheeler companies?

    Best regards
    Prashant

    1. N V Chandrachoodamani

      Thanks you sir

      It is an evolving industry and is difficult to rate success of any Co. at this stage. And even in incumbents, no player is a leader in more than two segments. For each, there is a focus/niche. There is also a low-speed segment that is doing much higher volumes and the e-Rickshaws.

      So, incumbents are not strong/successful across segments, each has their own focus/niche and there is this ‘Halo effect’ around some new entrants. Greaves is fully into the business with products, network, team and numbers.

      This is always the case with emerging sectors and early entry in to such stocks comes with risk.

      1. Dear Sir,

        Thank you for the detailed analysis of Greaves Cotton. Certainly a very good investment case in a niche and emerging sector accompanies with its own risks.

        Would like to understand your view regarding the recent strategic investment by Greaves in MLR Auto. Is it that competition is less in EV 3W space compared to 2W market.

        Best regards
        Sankar Venkidakrishnan

        1. N V Chandrachoodamani

          Thanks for your query sir

          Greaves had already acquired an electric 3W Co last year based in Noida. It sells ELE electric rickshaw, which is a different product from conventional auto-rickshaw. Can have a look at its products at ele3w.com

          Greaves had its DNA as diesel engine maker for 3Ws (Key supplier to Piaggio – APE Auto) and run a PAN India multi-brand spare parts network also. They seem to have a better understanding of 3W biz. So, their EV journey comprise of low speed 2W, high speed 2W and Passenger as well as Cargo 3W.

          This acquisition of MLR Auto is a part of acquiring the “platform” required to launch the conventional auto-rickshaws that we see, predominantly in south India. It can save time and cost of building a platform from scratch

          Hope his address your query sir, thank you

Comments are closed.

Hold On

You are being redirected to another page,
it may take a few seconds.

Login

Login_popup_image

Login

Don’t have an account ? Register for free

Become a PrimeInvestor!

Elevate Your Wealth with Professional Portfolio Management

Have an account?
Login_popup_image

Become a PrimeInvestor!

upi-qr-code